Metal vs Shingles: Which Roof Is Better for Your Home?
Last updated
Metal vs shingles comes down to upfront cost against lifespan. A metal roof costs about $5.50–$20.00 per sq ft installed and typically lasts 40–70 years. Asphalt shingles cost about $4.00–$8.00 and last 20–35 years, depending on climate, installation and maintenance. Compare the cost per year for your home below.
Metal vs shingles at a glance
| Feature | Metal | Asphalt shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per sq ft installed | $5.50–$20.00 | $4.00–$8.00 |
| Typical lifespan | 40–70 years | 20–35 years |
| Weight | Depends on the panel or metal shingle and its thickness. The manufacturer lists it per square. | Depends on the shingle type. The manufacturer lists it per bundle or per square. |
| Noise in rain | Depends mostly on the decking and attic insulation underneath. | Also depends on the decking and attic insulation underneath. |
| Appearance | Standing seam panels, or metal shingles shaped like shingles, slate or tile, in many colors. | 3-tab, architectural or premium designer shingles, in many colors. |
| Repairs | Done by a roofer who works with metal. Ask about matching the color and finish. | Damaged shingles can be replaced a few at a time. New ones may not match old ones exactly. |
| Resale | No guaranteed effect on the sale price. Buyers look at the roof’s age and condition. | No guaranteed effect on the sale price. Buyers look at the roof’s age and condition. |
Lifespans are typical ranges and depend on climate, installation and maintenance.
Sources: HomeGuide – Asphalt shingle roof cost; This Old House – New roof cost; HomeGuide – Metal roof cost; InterNACHI – Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart; Fixr – Asphalt shingles cost (3-tab, architectural, luxury). How we estimate
Metal vs shingle roof cost over the life of the roof
The upfront price is only half the picture. Dividing each installed cost by its typical lifespan gives a cost per year. That lets you compare two roofs that last different lengths of time. Enter your home below. We use a 6/12 pitch and one old layer removed for both.
Cost over the roof’s life
Free · no sign-up · results update as you type
Roof area about 2,214 sq ft (22.1 squares), 6/12 pitch, one old layer removed.
Asphalt shingle
- Installed cost
- $10,000–$24,400 typical $15,500
- Typical lifespan
- 20–35 years
- Cost per year of lifespan
- $280–$1,220 typical $560 a year
Metal
- Installed cost
- $13,300–$50,900 typical $27,700
- Typical lifespan
- 40–70 years
- Cost per year of lifespan
- $190–$1,270 typical $500 a year
An estimate, not a quote. Lifespans depend on climate, installation and maintenance.
When metal makes more sense
- You plan to stay in the home for a long time, and the cost per year above favors metal for your home.
- You like the look of standing seam panels, or metal shingles shaped like slate or tile.
- Local roofers with metal experience are available to install and service it.
- Your local code and HOA rules allow it, in the style and color you want.
When shingles make more sense
- The upfront price matters most, for example because you plan to sell before the roof wears out.
- You want the roof to match the homes around you, or HOA rules ask for shingles.
- You want a wide choice of roofers for installation and later repairs.
- The cost per year above is close for your home, and you prefer the lower upfront price.
Climate and local rules
Hail, high wind, heavy snow and salt air near the coast all test a roof in different ways. Ask local roofers which products they install for your area, and compare each product’s wind and impact ratings on its data sheet.
Check local code and HOA rules before you choose a material, style or color. Your roofer or local building department can tell you what applies to your address.
Energy and insulation
How much heat passes through a roof depends on the roof surface, the attic ventilation and the insulation, not on the material alone. Color and finish affect how much of the sun’s heat a roof absorbs.
Some metal and shingle products list a solar reflectance rating on their data sheet. If summer heat is a concern, ask your roofer for products with a rating and how they would handle attic ventilation.
Price your own roof
Price a metal roof for your home
Standing seam, metal shingles or exposed-fastener panels, for your home size and pitch.
Metal roof cost calculatorPrice an asphalt shingle roof
3-tab, architectural or premium shingles, for your home size and pitch.
Asphalt shingle roof cost calculatorMetal vs shingles questions
Is a metal roof better than shingles?
Neither is better for every home. Metal costs about $5.50–$20.00 per sq ft installed and lasts 40–70 years; shingles cost about $4.00–$8.00 and last 20–35 years. How long you plan to stay, your climate and local rules decide which suits you.
What is the metal vs shingle roof cost difference?
Installed, metal runs about $5.50–$20.00 per sq ft and asphalt shingles about $4.00–$8.00. Multiply by your roof area for the total, or enter your home in the calculator above to see both side by side.
Is metal worth it over shingles?
Compare the cost per year of lifespan, not only the upfront price. The calculator above divides each installed cost by its typical lifespan. If you expect to move before the roof wears out, the upfront price matters more.
Is a metal roof louder than shingles in rain?
It depends mostly on what is underneath. Solid decking and attic insulation change how much rain noise reaches the rooms below, for either material. Ask your roofer how they would install it on your house.
Which lasts longer, metal or shingles?
Typical lifespans are 40–70 years for metal and 20–35 years for asphalt shingles. Both depend on climate, installation and maintenance, so treat them as ranges, not promises.
Does a metal roof add value to a home?
There is no guaranteed effect on the sale price. Buyers tend to look at a roof’s age and condition. Keep the installer’s paperwork and any warranty documents to pass on.
How we estimate
- Prices: installed cost per square foot of roof area (US national average), built from named sources, each with the date we checked it, listed on our methodology page.
- Prices and lifespans: the general metal and asphalt shingle figures from our sourced cost data, installed per sq ft of roof.
- Installed cost: living area ÷ stories × 1.10 for overhangs × the 6/12 pitch multiplier, times the installed price per sq ft, plus one old layer torn off. A 6/12 roof gets no steep-roof factor.
- Cost per year: the installed low (before rounding) ÷ the longest lifespan, and the installed high ÷ the shortest; typical uses the middle of the lifespan range.
- Rounding: installed totals to the nearest $100 and cost per year to $10; prices per sq ft are shown exactly as sourced.
An estimate, not a quote. Get written quotes from licensed, insured roofers.